This publish might include affiliate hyperlinks. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please learn my disclosure.
When you’re in search of a hypoallergenic components in your child, you’ve doubtless come throughout two well-liked choices: HiPP HA vs. Nutramigen. On this parent-friendly information, I’ll discover these two toddler components choices, outlining their variations, the professionals and cons of every, and what to think about when selecting between these two formulation in your child.
When you’ve been looking for a hypoallergenic components, your child doubtless has already proven a few of the indicators of needing an HA components: discomfort when consuming, reflux, gasoline, constipation, and extra – all of which could be so anxious to cope with!
I’ve heard from a lot of you that my information to the greatest hypoallergenic formulation has made it simpler to decide on between the entire choices on the market, however that determining whether or not HiPP HA or Nutramigen is the appropriate alternative could be daunting!
I used to be fortunate sufficient to have two youngsters who didn’t have any allergy symptoms, however I’ve talked to so many dad and mom who’re confused about find out how to choose between HiPP HA and Nutramigen as a result of they’re not precisely an apples-to-apples comparability. In order that’s why I created this information, based mostly on my in depth data as a father or mother, licensed well being coach and nutritionist, and a whole bunch of hours working with households and researching toddler components. Let’s dive in!
HiPP HA, a European child components model freed from added sugar and syrup solids, is a wholesome, cost-effective different to Nutramigen in case your child has a cow’s milk protein sensitivity or a milder cow’s milk allergy.
Nutramigen, a US-manufactured components, accommodates as much as 47% syrup solids and could be dearer than HiPP HA, however could also be extra appropriate for infants with extreme identified CMPA. Be aware: Nutramigen was recalled in December 2023 for harmful micro organism (supply).
A Disclaimer & Methodology
As a board licensed well being coach and authorized nutritionist, I assist merchandise and components which might be rooted in science and are evidence-based. Utilizing my background in vitamin, together with in depth analysis (see under for particulars), consultations with specialists, and my very own private expertise giving my two youngsters components, I’ve created this information evaluating HiPP HA and Nutramigen.
My suggestions are based mostly on:
- Over 200 hours of intensive analysis
- Talking with 1000’s of oldsters on what has labored for his or her youngsters
- Reviewing each producers’ claims and components lists
- Talking with docs and pediatricians
- Reviewing numerous articles and peer-reviewed research
Although I’ll obtain a fee (at no additional expense to you) if you buy by means of a few of the affiliate hyperlinks supplied, I solely suggest merchandise I’ve researched, evaluated, consulted specialists on, and would really feel snug giving to my very own two youngsters.
As all the time, I solely share merchandise which might be the very best high quality and that may enable you to and your loved ones probably the most. By buying any of those merchandise from the hyperlinks under, you assist maintain this weblog working, so thanks in your assist!
Remember the fact that each child & scenario is completely different, so relating to selecting a child components, please seek the advice of together with your pediatrician first earlier than beginning or switching to a brand new components. My suggestions are usually not an alternative to skilled medical recommendation, analysis, or therapy.
What Are Completely different Sorts Of Hypoallergenic Method?
Let’s begin by wanting on the variations between hypoallergenic formulation and evaluating the 2 well-liked manufacturers, HiPP HA and Nutramigen.
Hypoallergenic child formulation are particularly designed for infants allergic to cow’s milk or cow’s milk protein, generally present in common toddler formulation.
These formulation are categorized into three sorts based mostly on how their proteins are processed: partially hydrolyzed, extensively hydrolyzed, and amino acid-based.
Partially Hydrolyzed Formulation
Partially hydrolyzed formulation are designed with proteins which have been partially damaged down, making them simpler to digest for infants who might have bother digesting entire proteins.
HiPP HA components accommodates partially hydrolyzed whey protein, about 86-87% derived from natural skim milk.
Extensively Hydrolyzed Formulation
Extensively hydrolyzed formulation include proteins which might be extensively damaged down into smaller items, which makes them much less prone to set off an allergic response.
Nutramigen is a components that accommodates hydrolyzed casein protein from milk. No less than 90% of the protein is damaged down into smaller items.
Amino Acid-Based mostly Formulation
Amino acid-based formulation are the least prone to trigger an allergic response since they include totally broken-down proteins into particular person amino acids.
Neither HiPP HA nor Nutramigen meets this requirement.
When Ought to You Select Hypoallergenic Method For Your Child?
In case your child reveals a sensitivity or allergy to cow’s milk protein, akin to colic, reflux, gasoline, different digestive points, or eczema, I like to recommend speaking to your pediatrician to see if switching to a hypoallergenic components might assist.
Hypoallergenic formulation might assist ease the signs of a milk protein allergy or sensitivity, as a result of, as talked about above, they’re made with hydrolyzed proteins, that are damaged down into smaller items which might be much less prone to set off an allergic response.
In each the US and Europe, dad and mom have entry to a wide range of hypoallergenic formulation for toddler vitamin. These formulation are designed to supply full toddler vitamin, together with all of the vitamins wanted for wholesome development and growth, whereas being light in your child’s delicate digestive system.
Evaluating These Two Manufacturers: Method Overview
HiPP HA
HiPP HA Combiotic is a specialised toddler components for infants inclined to the distinctive properties of cow’s milk proteins. These sensitivities can typically result in pores and skin or digestive points or hay fever-like signs, distressing each the infant and the dad and mom.
This components is designed to supply aid to such infants and accommodates hydrolyzed milk proteins that exclude casein, the protein sometimes liable for allergic reactions. These hydrolyzed proteins are simpler for infants to digest, making it an excellent alternative for infants with digestive points or who’re susceptible to colic. (Study Extra: Greatest Child Method For Colic).
Along with hydrolyzed milk proteins, HiPP HA Stage Combiotic additionally accommodates Pure Lactic Acid Tradition (Lactobacillus Fermentum Hereditum®²), which helps to enhance intestine well being and increase the immune system. The components additionally features a good stability of proteins, nutritional vitamins, minerals, ARA (Omega-6), and DHA (Omega-3), guaranteeing that your child receives all the required vitamins for wholesome development and growth.
Partially hydrolyzed milk proteins
Comprises prebiotics & probiotics
Comprises largely natural or biodynamic components
Not extensively hydrolyzed, so might not work for extreme allergy symptoms
Comprises the identical quantity of lactose as an everyday components, so might not work for infants with a lactose intolerance
Enfamil Nutramigen
Nutramigen with LGG® is a specialised components for infants with identified delicate to reasonable cow’s milk protein allergy symptoms. It undergoes in depth hydrolysis and is expertly crafted to stop allergic reactions in most infants. This components supplies a hypoallergenic resolution for folks who search a secure dietary choice for his or her infants with out compromising on the important vitamins required for development and growth.
It is available in two formulations – a powdered model and a shelf-stable, liquid model. The important thing distinction between the 2 is that the powdered model has a better quantity of added sugar and syrup solids (47%), whereas the liquid model a a lot decrease quantity of syrup solids (5%), but it surely accommodates carrageenan, which can trigger irritation within the physique (supply).
Nutramigen generally is a dependable resolution for households to handle CMPA and to scale back colic and gasoline of their infants.
Extensively hydrolyzed and hypoallergenic, appropriate for lactose sensitivities and cow’s milk protein allergy symptoms
Consists of LGG: An extensively studied probiotic for allergy administration and supporting the digestive well being of your child
One stage for infants 0-12 months
No carrageenan within the powdered model
Comprises corn syrup solids (the primary ingredient, and is 47% of the components within the powdered model)
Comprises added starch (4% of the components)
Comprises palm oil and soy oil
Model Popularity: Enfamil Nutramigen Vs. HiPP HA
Nutramigen Popularity
Nutramigen is a child components manufactured by Enfamil, a well known and revered model within the business. It has been round since 1942 – that’s 82 years! As a result of it’s manufactured within the US, it is usually regulated by the FDA. This components is hypoallergenic and particularly designed to handle colic, ensuing from a cow’s milk protein allergy. Aid is promised inside 48 hours.
Nutramigen has all the time had an excellent popularity in the US as being a good model, whose formulation that may scale back and handle cow’s milk protein allergy signs.
Nevertheless, in December 2023, 1000’s of cans of Nutramigen needed to be recalled as a result of Cronobacter sakazakii, a micro organism that may trigger extreme infections. That is the second time in lower than a 12 months that the producer, Reckitt/Mead Johnson Diet, has needed to recall their product (supply).
Since there’s already a major scarcity of child components (supply), these recollects are inflicting households to be involved in regards to the oversight within the components business. You will discover extra details about the recall on the corporate’s web site at enfamil.com.
HiPP HA Popularity
HiPP is a well known and revered European model with over 50 years of expertise producing high-quality natural child components. It’s well known for its dedication to sustainable farming practices and utilizing solely the best components that meet the very best natural requirements. HiPP has constructed a loyal following amongst dad and mom in search of a more healthy different to standard child formulation.
Their in depth vary of merchandise contains numerous toddler milk components choices and a wide range of complementary meals for infants and toddlers. All are rigorously formulated to supply optimum vitamin for infants and younger youngsters.
The HiPP HA line is a specialised components for infants’ sensitivities to exploit proteins. This components is made with hydrolyzed protein, which makes it simpler for infants to digest and has been clinically confirmed to scale back allergy signs. The HiPP HA line has acquired many constructive evaluations from dad and mom who’ve seen vital enhancements of their infants’ digestion and allergy signs.
Hipp HA: This well-established model has over 50 years of expertise and is understood for its natural formulation, high-quality components, sustainable farming practices, and constructive evaluations for delicate infants.
Nutramigen: This model has over 80 years of expertise, is FDA-regulated, and is manufactured by Enfamil. It’s clinically designed to handle the signs of cow’s milk protein allergy. Sadly there was multiple recall as a result of dangerous micro organism.
HiPP HA Vs. Nutramigen: Diet
Let’s check out how HiPP HA and Nutramigen examine relating to their components and vitamin. I’m going to evaluation each of those formulation’ protein content material, carbohydrate supply, the kinds of fat used, and whether or not every other particular components (probiotics, prebiotics, and many others.) are included.
Protein Content material
As talked about above, if a child has an allergy or sensitivity to cow’s milk protein, they are often given partially or extensively hydrolyzed formulation. Hydrolysis includes breaking down the proteins into smaller parts or peptides. The diploma of hydrolysis determines whether or not a components is partially or extensively hydrolyzed.
Hipp HA
Hipp HA is a components that accommodates partially hydrolyzed whey protein derived from natural skim milk. The partial hydrolysis course of breaks down round 86-87% of cows’ milk proteins.
Nutramigen
Nutramigen options extensively hydrolyzed casein protein derived from milk. The in depth hydrolyzation course of breaks down over 90% of the cow’s milk proteins.
Carbohydrate Content material
Many child formulation include lactose and/or corn syrup as the first carbohydrate, but it surely’s essential to notice that not all carbohydrates are the identical. Lactose is a pure sugar in milk. However corn syrup is a sweetener from corn starch, basically added sugar.
Though lactose and corn syrup can present power for infants to develop and develop, lactose is the popular carbohydrate supply for toddler vitamin. It’s because it’s the first carb supply in breast milk, simply digestible, and supplies a gentle power provide.
Conversely, corn syrup is a extremely processed sweetener that, whereas secure in small quantities, will not be the best choice in your child. (Study Extra: Corn Syrup In Child Method).
The first carbohydrate supply in HiPP HA is lactose, much like the one present in breast milk. Consequently, HiPP HA carefully mimics the pure composition of breast milk and supplies an simply digestible carbohydrate supply for infants.
Nutramigen depends on corn syrup solids as its main carbohydrate supply. This differs from the lactose present in breast milk and Hipp HA, however corn syrup solids can present power with out aggravating potential sensitivities associated to lactose intolerance.
Nevertheless, this carb supply does rely as added sugars, and should influence your youngster’s consuming habits sooner or later (supply). Additionally, some research have advised that infants who acquired components with corn syrup-based carbohydrates had a better danger of extra antagonistic well being impacts, however this analysis continues to be ongoing (supply).
Fat And Oils
Breast milk and components milk each include fat, proteins, carbohydrates, and plenty of different vitamins important for the infant’s development and growth. Fats contributes nearly half of the energy in breast milk and components, offering the power required for the infant’s growth.
Hipp HA’s fats content material is derived from natural vegetable oils, akin to palm, rapeseed, and sunflower. These oils present the important fatty acids for optimum toddler mind and eye growth.
Nutramigen’s fats supply combines non-organic vegetable oils, together with palm olein, coconut, soy, and high-oleic sunflower.
Probiotics And Prebiotics
Prebiotics are non-digestible meals fibers that stimulate the expansion of excellent micro organism in your child’s intestine. (Study Extra: Prebiotics For Children). On the identical time, probiotics are stay microorganisms that present well being advantages when consumed in sufficient quantities. (Study Extra: Probiotics For Child Constipation).
Hipp HA
Hipp HA components has a particular ingredient known as galactooligosaccharides (GOS), that are prebiotic fibers much like these present in breast milk. These fibers assist promote the expansion of excellent intestine micro organism, which in flip helps keep balanced intestine flora.
The Hipp HA components additionally accommodates a pure probiotic lactic acid tradition known as Lactobacillus fermentum, initially extracted from breast milk. Combining prebiotics and probiotics helps assist the infant’s immune system and digestion, maintaining your infant wholesome.
Nutramigen
Nutramigen is more practical than different extensively hydrolyzed protein formulation as a result of it accommodates LGG® (Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG), probably the most researched probiotic for managing allergy symptoms in infants. LGG® helps to handle cow’s milk protein allergy and promotes the expansion of a balanced intestine flora that enhances immune well being. Nutramigen doesn’t include prebiotics.
HiPP HA is a nutritionally full components for infants that’s made with natural components. It makes use of lactose as its main carbohydrate and accommodates no corn syrup solids. It has 86-87% hydrolyzed milk proteins and makes use of natural vegetable oils as its fats supply. It accommodates each prebiotics and probiotics.
Nutramigen can be nutritionally full for infants. It makes use of corn syrup solids as its main carbohydrate supply and is lactose-free. It has 90% hydrolyzed milk proteins, and makes use of non-organic vegetable oils as its fats supply. It accommodates probiotics, it doesn’t include prebiotics. It doesn’t include natural components.
Price: HiPP HA Vs. Nutramigen
In my analysis, I’ve discovered that the majority hypoallergenic formulation are dearer than their customary components counterparts, primarily as a result of specialised components wanted for these formulation.
In terms of the price of Hipp HA and Nutramigen, HiPP HA is the extra reasonably priced alternative. Hipp HA is usually round $2 per ounce. However, Nutramigen might price extra, at round $3 per ounce.
Method Availability
HiPP HA Availability
Whereas HiPP HA is made in Europe, there are lots of respected distributors of this components that may ship to the US! I’ve reviewed many of those distributors and have discovered that this European child components web site – TheMilkyBox – is a dependable supply to buy from, and HiPP HA is all the time out there on their web site.
I personally ordered from them and beloved the comfort of getting HiPP delivered straight to my doorstep in all levels. I felt relieved that it was really easy to get components, figuring out my child’s dietary wants had been effectively taken care of with out leaving the consolation of my house.
Nutramigen Availability
Nutramigen could be bought by means of conventional retail channels in the US and is obtainable at Amazon, Goal, and Walmart. Nevertheless, as a result of shutdown of the biggest Abbott plant within the nation in 2022 and subsequent bacterial contamination, Nutramigen could also be much less available and is typically out of inventory.
Each HiPP HA and Nutramigen could be discovered on-line, and Nutramigen could be present in choose shops in the US as effectively. HiPP HA is barely cheaper than Nutramigen.
HiPP HA is all the time available, and has had no points with recollects or being out of inventory. Nutramigen has had points with recollects and is typically out of inventory, making it more durable to seek out at occasions.
Abstract: Variations Between HiPP HA Vs. Nutramigen
| HiPP HA | Nutramigen | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Germany | United States |
| Producer | HiPP Natural | Enfamil |
| Overview | Is available in 3 levels, solely out there as a powdered model. Regulated by the European Union. | Just one stage, out there as both a powdered or liquid (ready-to-feed) model. Regulated by the FDA. |
| Model Popularity | 50 years of expertise. Is understood for its natural formulation, sustainable farming practices, prime quality components, and constructive evaluations for delicate infants. | 80+ years of expertise, well-known delicate components model. Sadly, there have been multiple recall as a result of dangerous micro organism. |
| Major Protein Supply | Partially hydrolyzed whey protein from natural skim milk (86-87%) | Extensively hydrolyzed casein protein from milk (90%+) |
| Carbohydrate Content material | Lactose from milk | Corn syrup solids |
| Carbohydrate Advantages | Light on child’s tummy, nearer to breastmilk composition | Appropriate for infants with lactose intolerance and identified CMPA |
| Fat and Oils | Natural vegetable oils together with palm, rapeseed, and sunflower | Non-organic vegetable oils together with palm olein, coconut, soy, and excessive oleic sunflower |
| Prebiotics and Probiotics | Comprises galactooligosaccharides (GOS) and probiotic Lactobacillus fermentum | Comprises LGG® probiotic |
| Value Per Ounce | Roughly $2 | Roughly $3 |
| Availability | Simply discovered at TheMilkyBox.com and delivered to your door, all the time in inventory. | Obtainable to buy on Amazon, Goal, and Walmart, however has had points with being out of inventory as a result of components shortages and recollects. |
FAQ’s
Try this fast information to assist get your loved ones began on switching child components.
Hypoallergenic formulation can begin to relieve signs as shortly as 48 hours, with most infants discovering probably the most consolation inside 2-3 weeks.
The reply is, it is dependent upon the wants of your child! In case your child has a light or reasonable allergy or sensitivity, no lactose allergy, and also you’re in search of a extra reasonably priced components with natural components and no corn syrup solids, then I might suggest making an attempt HiPP HA first. But when your child is allergic to lactose and / or has a extreme cow’s milk protein allergy, Nutramigen could be the higher alternative.
Ultimate Ideas
Hydrolyzed protein formulation are all completely different, however HiPP HA and Nutramigen are two of the extra well-liked choices. Each have professionals and cons, and relying on what your child’s particular allergy symptoms are, both could be the appropriate alternative.
Personally, if my child had a cow’s milk sensitivity or a reasonable allergy, I might select HiPP HA as a result of it has a stronger model popularity, is extra reasonably priced, has greater high quality, natural components, and no corn syrup solids.
Nevertheless, if my child had a extreme lactose allergy or extreme CMPA, HiPP HA will not be damaged down sufficient, and I’ll don’t have any alternative however to make use of Nutramigen, which is designed for infants with extra extreme allergy symptoms.
Regardless, in case your child has a delicate digestive system or is displaying indicators of allergy symptoms, I might suggest that you just discuss to your youngster’s pediatrician about selecting a components that accommodates hydrolyzed protein.
